Thursday, March 26, 2020

Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Gabriel Garcia Marquez


An analysis of the title:

Chronicle: related to past or record of past
Foretell: predict the future or a future event; oriented to future.
Therefore , the two words pull into different directions and destabilize the meaning.
The title also for the same reason creates suspense – how is the death foretold and how is it chronicled?
If the death is foretold , is the chronicle going to be predictive as the title suggests or retrospective.


What is a chronicle?

chronicle (Latinchronica, from Greek χρονικά chroniká, from χρόνοςchrónos – "time") is a historical account of facts and events arranged in chronological order, as in a time line

According to the Dictionary of Literary Terms and Literary Theory, a  ‘chronicle’ is a ‘register of events in order of time, often composed contemporaneously with the events it records’(Cuddon. 124).

Typically,
equal weight is given for historically important events and local events,
the purpose being the recording of events that occurred, seen from the perspective of the chronicler.

Characteristics: 
This is in contrast to a narrative or history, which sets selected events in a meaningful interpretive context and excludes those the author does not see as important.


Live chronicles

Usually, a ‘live chronicle’ is a chronicle is recorded as the events happen.
This chronicle, is however, a narrative of events that took place twenty-seven years earlier.
At the same time, the chronicle mentions the very feelings and words that the characters uttered around the focal event.

Reliability of Chronicles:  The information sources vary; some chronicles are written from first-hand knowledge, some are from witnesses or participants in events, still others are accounts passed mouth to mouth prior to being written down.

Some used written material: Charters, letters, or the works of earlier chroniclers.
Still others are tales of such unknown origins so as to hold mythical status.
The reliability of a particular chronicle is an important determination for modern historians.
Connection to text:
  In Marquez’s Chronicle  eye-witness accounts as well as versions collected from different participants feature.

Novels-I Lessons for MA(English) I Year


Subject: Novels-I

Lesson: The Novel

Novel as a term

The word 'novel' is an adjective, it stands for that which is  'new'  and does not resemble anything formerly 'known or used'. It suggests a thing or process 'not previously identified' just as the transmission of a novel corona virus.

Furthermore,  the word denotes something  'original and striking in conception or style'. For instance, the Indian government's novel strategies to combat the corona pandemic. Refer to: Merriam Webster.
But 'novel' is also a noun. It is a term used to label 'an invented prose narrative that is usually long and complex and deals especially with human experience through a usually connected sequence of events. It refers to a literary genre.

Now, we deal with the term 'Novel' considering  its literary meaning  at some length.

What is a Novel?

A novel is a piece of prose fiction of a reasonable length. As a genre, a novel defies definition. For Terry Eagleton then, a novel is 'less a genre than an anti-genre'( The English Novel: An Introduction. Wiley-Blackwell).

Eagleton asserts that a novel as a literary genre ' cannibalizes other literary modes and mixes bits and pieces promiscuously together'(1). He adds that the novel 'quotes, parodies and transforms other genres'. The novel is a 'mighty melting pot, a mongrel among literary thoroughbreds' remarks Eagleton.

The form of a novel is 'particularly associated with the middle class, it is partly because the ideology of that class centres on a dream of freedom' from old conventions- the old certainties of God and old autocratic order.

Nature

Most commentators agree that the novel has its roots in the literary form identified as 'romance' (2). The romance of the bourgeoisie-which is the novel-  is different. It is a 'disenchanted' romance that  has to 'negotiate  the prosaic world of modern civilization' where 'money and marriage / Sex and property' are the themes from start to finish.

History and Associations

The novel was born at the same time as modern science, and shares its sober, secular, hard-headed, investigative spirit, along with its suspicion of classical authority.

In The Rise of the Novel Ian Watt finds the reasons for emergence of the novel in the eighteenth-century( as modern English novel) in the middle-class interest in individual psychology, its secular and empiricist view of the world  nd its devotion to the concrete and specific (11. qtd . Eagleton).

For many eighteenth -century commentators the novel was a 'trashy piece of fiction fit only for servants and females' observes Eagleton.  The label stood for writing that was merely somekind of 'sensationalist fantasy' and  due to this notoriety Henry Fielding and Samuel Richardson called their works 'histories' instead.

The 'new' at this time meant either 'bogus or trivial'. The novel was not considered 'literature' or 'art' at all but inferior sort of production.

If the novel is the modern epic , it is, in Georg Lukacs's famous phrase , 'the epic of a world abandoned by God'. As the novel evolves it starts to shun the earlier attempts to represent a 'coherent or logical ' universe and starts reflecting the incoherent and fragmented world of man , especially in the aftermath of the First World War. This is visible in the break-up of language, the collapse of narrative, the dissolution of character and the disappearance of plot. Moreover, the new devices foregrounding the unreliability of reports and the clash of subjective standpoints, the fragility of value, and the elusiveness of meaning make the novel a literary counterpart of the suffering humanity and its failure to understand existence.

Examples for:

1. Break-up of language: Cervantes draws attention to the pomposity of language used in 'romances' by constantly applying  hyperbole and underlining it with humour not only in the content of the dialogue but also in the farcical action and slapstick comedy that makes the romance of Don Quixote descend to the level of a picareque novel or an anti-bildungsroman.

2.The collapse of narrative: Marquez's Chronicle of a Death Foretold where the ambiguity and equivocation is so great that all versions contradict each other; In Don Quixote, the narrator constantly asks the reader to doubt to the author and the whole narrative endeavour beginning at the outset.

3. Clash of subjective viewpoints: Cervantes' Don Quixote; Marquez' Chronicle.

4. The fragility of value: Don Quixote- he rescues the odd-job boy but the rescue leads to greater problem as his master beats him more after the knight leaves; the chivalric code does not mention money or routine requirements but Don Quixote must pay  for his shelter and food; In Crime and Punishment  Raskolnikov who kills an old pawnbroker to deliver humanity just as Napolean would have done.

5. Bare plot: Marquez's Chronicle does not have a fully-developed ploy but a host of narratives and reports surrounding a particular horrific incident; Similarly, Kafka's stories like 'The Metamorphosis'  do not bank on plot but a pathological state of mind visible in a transformed world that appears surreal and apparently illogical.

6. Dissolution of character: Gabriel Garcia Marquez's Chronicle of a Death Foretold. No character is comprehensible, not even Santiago Nasar whose death is the focus of the narrative as all reports and versions contradict each other leaving nothing certain about the character of either the protagonists or the other characters in the novella. Similarly, Raskolnikov's motives are so mixed up and diverse that even he has difficulty pinning down his thoughts or expressing his convictions. He constantly revises, reviews and contradicts his positions to the extent that when he commits the murder it is more mechanical than voluntarily done. The deed does not seem to be executed out of freewill but because of a wheel set in motion and a series of coincidences and accidents propelling the character to carry out a theory in practice.

Summary and Pre-requisites:

Novel is a fictitious prose narrative of book length, typically representing character and action with some degree of realism.

Required terms/concepts:

1.      Difference between prose and poetry/verse.
2.      Meaning of narrative
3.      Character
4.      Action
5.      Realism

Eagleton asserts, 'Not all novels are realist, but realism is the dominant style of the modern English novel'. Realistic characters are credible, well-rounded and psychologically complex. Realism is organic to the bourgeoisie world with its belief in the material realities of everyday existence; its impatience withthe formal, ceremonial and metaphysical; its love for the palpable, measurable and utilitarian and its insatiable curiosity about the individual self and its robust faith in historical progress.

End  notes:
Bildungsroman
/ˈbɪldʊŋzrəʊˌmɑːn/

noun
1.      a novel dealing with one person's formative years or spiritual education.
"the book is a bildungsroman of sorts, as Tull overcomes his abused childhood and learns about love".

picaresque
/ˌpɪkəˈrɛsk/

adjective
adjective: picaresque
1.      relating to an episodic style of fiction dealing with the adventures of a rough and dishonest but appealing hero.
"a picaresque adventure novel"
Origin
https://www.gstatic.com/onebox/dictionary/etymology/en/desktop/f1c2365ef99770bd3b2c5185b2115a7e96a1039753fdaa08ee820ac232a715fd.png
early 19th century: from French, from Spanish picaresco, from pícaro ‘rogue’.